MyRenewals vs Notion for Contract Renewal Tracking

Notion is a powerful knowledge base and project tool. Many teams use it for contract tracking by building a database with renewal date properties. It works for simple cases — until you need proactive alerts.

Try MyRenewals Free →

The Honest Assessment

Notion is genuinely excellent at what it does. If you want a central wiki, project tracker, and knowledge base all in one place, it's hard to beat. Building a contract database in Notion with renewal date properties is straightforward — you can have something working in an hour.

The fundamental gap is alerts. Notion has no native email notification system for date-based triggers. It can show you that a contract is due in 30 days — but only if you open Notion and look at your database. It will not email you. To get email alerts from Notion, you need a third-party automation tool like Zapier or Make, a paid plan on that tool, and someone to build and maintain the automation logic.

MyRenewals sends the email automatically. Set up your renewals once and alerts fire at 90, 60, 30, and 7 days before each deadline — no Zapier, no Make, no automation logic to build or maintain.

Where Notion Falls Short for Renewal Tracking

These aren't criticisms of Notion as a product — they're the natural limits of using a knowledge base tool for a proactive alerting use case.

🔔

No Built-In Email Alerts

Notion can show you when something is due, but it cannot send you an email. To get email alerts, you need a third-party automation tool — Zapier, Make, or similar — which adds cost, requires setup, and needs ongoing maintenance. If the automation breaks, alerts stop silently and you won't know until you miss a renewal.

🔧

Reminders Are Manual and In-App Only

Notion's native reminder feature sends in-app or Slack notifications, not email. It also requires someone to manually add a reminder to each database entry — there's no automatic reminder based on a date field. For a database of 50 contracts, that's 50 manual reminders to set and maintain.

🏗️

No Renewal-Specific Workflow

Notion is a blank canvas — there's no concept of a "notice period", a multi-stage alert cadence, or a renewal history log. You have to build all of this yourself using database properties and formulas, and maintain it when something changes. Every user ends up with a slightly different system that breaks when the person who built it is unavailable.

📊

Scales Poorly With Many Contracts

Notion databases work well up to around 50 rows but become slow and hard to navigate with hundreds of contracts across multiple clients, suppliers, or departments. Filtering, sorting, and viewing urgent renewals across a large contract estate is not what Notion databases are designed for.

Feature Comparison

Feature Notion MyRenewals
Automatic email alerts (90/60/30/7 days)Third-party automation required Built in
Works out of the box Requires setup
Purpose-built for renewals
Notice period trackingFormula required
Full audit historyPage history only
CSV import
Free plan available (no email alerts) 10 renewals
Maintenance requiredOngoingNone

When to Use Which

Choose Notion if…

  • You already use Notion for everything and want contracts alongside your other docs
  • You have fewer than 20 contracts and check dates manually as a habit
  • You have a team member who can build and maintain Zapier automations
  • You need contract information alongside project notes and documentation

Choose MyRenewals if…

  • You need email alerts without building and maintaining automations
  • You track contracts for multiple clients or departments
  • You need a compliance-ready audit history of renewal decisions
  • You want something that just works the same way for every user from day one

Stop building — start tracking

MyRenewals is ready to use the moment you sign up. No automations to configure, no Zapier account required.

Start Free Today